Perfectionism and Anxiety: Is Pride Just Insecurity in Disguise?
Vanessa Stewart
Some of the most prideful people are often the most insecure. There’s a common misconception that prideful people are bold, arrogant, and think quite highly of themselves. Of course, this is true in many cases, but it may not be typical.
More often, pride comes out of insecurity. Pride manifests in the places where people are the most unsure of themselves or are the most afraid of being exposed. Pride really shines in those fragile parts of their lives where they’re the most desperate for approval.
Pride and insecurity might look like opposites on the surface, but if you dig deep enough, you’ll find that they often share the same root. Someone who is insecure will often try to prove that they are worthy. Outwardly, this looks like confidence, but it’s actually more of a defense mechanism.
Insecure Pride as a Defense
Pride can be difficult to spot sometimes because it wears a lot of different masks. One of those masks is defensiveness. In the real world, this might look like someone’s need to win every argument or to be looked upon as the smart one in the friend group. It could also manifest as a refusal to apologize or to admit weakness. Sometimes it even shows itself as perfectionism and anxiety.
Someone who appears prideful might actually feel inadequate, and they might become highly critical of others. If they can’t measure up to the accomplishments of someone else, they might criticize and try to bring that person down to their level.
Prideful people also have a difficult time apologizing or admitting their own mistakes. They might cover up their failings or try to project them onto someone else. This can manifest as phrases such as “You made me do it” or “If you hadn’t done that, I wouldn’t have done this.” Prideful people rarely take responsibility for their own failures because they don’t want to add another mistake to what they believe is an already lengthy list of their flaws.
As destructive as they are, prideful behaviors are sometimes praised and admired because they can look quite attractive. They might look like confidence to the world, a trait often praised in our society. This praise reinforces the behavior because it also feeds the person’s ego. This creates a cycle of behavior. But when you look a little deeper, under the fake confidence, you will likely see that these behaviors are protecting fragile self-esteem.
The Cycle of Pride
When someone fears being rejected, they might present themselves as superior in an attempt to convince themselves and their audience of their worth. Because they don’t believe they can meet someone else’s standard, they puff themselves up, trying to appear better than others.
Pride and insecurity are both part of a larger cycle. Insecurity creates a fear of exposure. Protective pride in the form of arrogance or perfectionism creates a temporary ego boost, which pressures you to maintain this false mask. And the knowledge that you’re falsely elevating yourself or are inauthentically being propped up by others creates even deeper insecurity.
Pride in the Bible
The Bible has quite a lot to say about pride. Scripture consistently warns that pride can lead to a destructive path. Proverbs 16 tells us plainly that “Pride goes before destruction, a haughty spirit before a fall.” (Proverbs 16:18, NIV)
What does pride mean in this context? In this passage, pride does not refer to confidence or feeling good about yourself. Feeling confident in the creation God made you to be is not a detriment, but a goal. Biblically speaking, pride refers to an inflated view of oneself that pushes God and others out of their proper place. It is a posture of the heart that believes it’s better than anyone and doesn’t need correction.
The Hebrew word used here in Proverbs for pride is gaon. At its core, it means height or majesty. When used negatively, as it is in this context, it refers to an inflated view of oneself that pushes God and others out of their proper place. It’s the idea of rising above others in a falsely elevated way.
This can happen through arrogance, prideful elevation of oneself, self-exaltation, or a sense of superiority. Proverbs 16:18, in the original text, also uses a related idea, ruach gavoah, which means a high or lofty spirit. Together, these terms paint a picture of someone who has lifted themselves to appear more important than they actually are.
Having pride has become a badge of honor in modern culture. Biblically, elevation belongs to God, not us. By puffing up (gaon), we create an attitude that eventually causes the fall that Proverbs warns about.
Scripture also helps us understand that pride can hide insecurity. In Luke 18, Jesus tells a story about two men who went to the temple to pray. One was a Pharisee, a man who would have been respected in his day for his religious devotion. The other was a tax collector, someone whom most of his contemporaries would have called corrupt.
The Pharisee prayed confidently: “‘God, I thank you that I am not like other people, robbers, evildoers, adulterers, or even like this tax collector. I fast twice a week and give a tenth of all I get.’” (Luke 18:11-12, NIV)
The tax collector took an opposite posture. Scripture says he stood at a distance and wouldn’t even look up to heaven. He didn’t have a long and eloquent prayer, but simply said, “God, have mercy on me, a sinner.” (Luke 18:13, NIV)
The result might surprise you. The tax collector, not the prideful Pharisee, went home justified before God (Luke 18:14) because the tax collector was honest. He wasn’t comparing himself to anyone or trying to prove his worth. He simply admitted his need while the Pharisee was busy defending his own worth.
Pride Is Exhausting
Maintaining an image, like the Pharisee in our example, takes a lot of effort. If your identity depends on appearing strong, capable, or morally superior, then you are constantly attempting to manage how others see you.
Every interaction or conversation, the ones most people don’t give much thought to, becomes heavily important when you are protecting your curated image. Constructive criticism is viewed as an attack, and every mistake is seen as an enemy. That responsibility can be downright exhausting.
God Is Our Peace
What brings peace and can quiet those insecurities and squelch that pride?
Humility is often misunderstood. Many people assume that humility is thinking poorly of yourself. But that’s not biblical humility at all. Humility is simply seeing yourself accurately. It is the ability to recognize your strengths without exaggerating, as well as your weaknesses without cover-up. This accurate self-assessment actually creates emotional freedom.
Humility recognizes grace. When you can admit your frailties, limitations, and mistakes, you leave room for God’s forgiveness and grace. Your IQ, test score, paycheck, or social media presence isn’t going to ever be good enough to get you to Heaven.
“For it is by grace you have been saved, through faith – and this is not from yourselves, it is the gift of God – not by works, so that no one can boast.” (Ephesians 2:8-9, NIV) That realization alone can be humbling and remove the need for pride.
Therapy Can Help
Many prideful behaviors stem from old insecurities. Maybe the mistakes you made as a child were harshly criticized or constantly compared to others. Pride then can become a shield or a way to compensate for that lingering sense of inadequacy.
Therapy can help you trace your prideful behaviors back to their roots. When you stop trying to maintain a perfect image, you open yourself up to growth. You can finally deal with the underlying issues. When you do this, something beautiful and authentic happens.
You will begin to feel safe enough to acknowledge your own limitations, fears, or weaknesses. You will find a place of humility. And with this self-actualization, the need for pride and the perfectionism and anxiety that often come with it will start to fade, leaving room for the awesome work God wants to do in you.
If you need help addressing issues of insecurity or pride, call our offices and make an appointment. Specially trained therapists can help you grow in your humility and embrace the grace of a God who does not require perfection.
https://biblehub.com/lexicon/proverbs/16-18.htm
https://enduringword.com/Bible-commentary/luke-18/
Photo:
“In the Kitchen”, Courtesy of Chang Duong, Unsplash.com, CC0 License;


